Another Georgia lawmaker accused of pandemic unemployment fraud

ATLANTA — Federal prosecutors have charged another Georgia lawmaker with making false statements to fraudulently obtain thousands of dollars of pandemic unemployment assistance.

Rep. Dexter Sharper, D-Valdosta, was arraigned on Friday on charges of making false statements to obtain $13,825 in unemployment assistance benefits to which he was not entitled, according to U.S. Attorney Theodore Hertzberg of the Northern District of Georgia.

Sharper had filed federal forms during the pandemic asserting that he had one employer, Dexter Sharper Party Rental, and had not worked since March 13, 2020, filing certifications during the next 38 weeks that he had no income, Hertzberg’s office said.

But prosecutors said he was receiving at least $325 a week from the Georgia General Assembly, generating up to $2,231 in income a week from his party rental business, and collecting up to $275 a week for work as a musician.

Sharper is the third Georgia state representative accused of defrauding the COVID-19 unemployment program.

Former Rep. Karen Bennet, D-Stone Mountain, pleaded guilty in federal court to making false statements to fraudulently obtain $13,940 in federal emergency relief, Hertzberg’s office said earlier this month.

And Rep. Sharon Henderson, D-Covington, was charged in December with making false statements to obtain $17,811 in unemployment benefits to which she was not entitled. Henderson pleaded not guilty. Gov. Brian Kemp suspended her from office last week pending the outcome of her case or the end of her term.

Smokers have left the building, yet the influence of tobacco lingers

ATLANTA — Some lawmakers have been working under Georgia’s Gold Dome long enough to remember when the place reeked of cigarettes.

Although no one openly smokes there today, lawmakers seem to have an abiding aversion to legislation to curb tobacco use, specifically a tax increase.

Rep. Ron Stephens, R-Savannah, took his oath of office in 1997. The white-haired pharmacist has personal reasons to abhor cigarettes, and he has been introducing legislation against tobacco since his hair was black.

But some mysterious force has always undermined his efforts.

He and a fellow Republican who chairs the House Public and Community Health committee have been tilting at a tobacco windmill for most of their legislative careers, and they have little to show for it.

After numerous hours invested last spring and summer in a study committee that underscored the dangers of tobacco use, they feel defeated.

“I don’t know why anything related to tobacco has trouble getting through,” said Rep. Sharon Cooper, R-Marietta, the public health committee chairwoman who also led the smoking study committee.

It is not as if the risks of smoking are a secret.

The report written by their five-member study committee makes that plain. It starts off by noting that the resolution passed by the full House to establish the committee had recognized that smoking “harms every organ” in the body.

The report then summarized facts gathered during three hearings: cigarette smoke can produce more than 7,000 chemicals, including ammonia, formaldehyde, lead, mercury and uranium-235. It can cause, among other things, cancer, heart and lung disease, type 2 diabetes, eye diseases, and rheumatoid arthritis.

Both Stephens and Cooper have personal motivations, as well.

Stephens’ sister-in-law died last summer, due, he said, to the effects of smoking. For years, she had been confined at home, tethered to an oxygen bottle. He said his father smoked as a teen and got lung concern later in life, which cost $5,000 a month to treat.

Cooper’s half-sister died in her 30s, and the lawmaker always suspected it was due to secondhand smoke exposure from her chain-smoking stepmother.

As a licensed nurse, Cooper said she had witnessed the damage. “I’ve seen lungs blackened over years of smoking,” she said.

Both also spoke of the resulting financial burden for taxpayers.

“You’re going to get sick, usually when you’re older and on Medicare or Medicaid,” Stephens said, “so then the public bears the cost.”

Yet nothing concrete has come of the hours they spent on their study committee. The discussion during the hearings suggested a clear direction: legislation to raise the tax on cigarettes.

Georgia’s cigarette excise tax has not changed since 2003. At 37 cents a pack, it is the second lowest in the nation, behind only Missouri. By comparison, New York charges $5.35 per pack, and Indianna increased its tax by $2 a pack in 2024, lifting it to $2.99.

Stephens was not surprised to learn that the American Lung Association had yet again given Georgia a failing grade. This week, the organization released its 24th annual “State of Tobacco Control” report.

Georgia got an “F” in all five categories related to curbing tobacco use. The association recommended that lawmakers increase the state’s cigarette tax by at least $1.50 per pack. It said studies show that every 10% increase in the price of cigarettes reduces consumption by about 4% among adults and about 7% among youth.

The association said tobacco use is the leading cause of preventable death and disease nationally and claims 11,690 Georgia lives each year.

Rep. Michelle Au, D-Johns Creek, was not surprised by the failing grades.

“We’ve been five Fs for a long time,” said Au, a medical doctor and one of two Democrats on Cooper’s study committee.

Dr. Au observed something unusual for a study committee report. “It is denuded of policy recommendations,” she said. “We were told in the process that we could not include policy recommendations.”

She said she asked House Speaker Jon Burns, R-Newington, who had empaneled the study committee, why it was given such instructions.

“And he said (it was) because there were such strong feelings on either side of the issue that he felt that the best approach would be to just present the facts,” Au said. “Of course, I did notice that basically every other study committee does present policy recommendations.”

Indeed, one of the three study committee meetings focused on policy recommendations, she said. “So, it is a conspicuous omission.”

A spokeswoman for Burns’ office said he had instructed the committee to present “the entirety” of the data and testimony gathered by the committee “so that the General Assembly’s future legislative initiatives could be informed and guided by the facts.”

Republicans control both the state Senate and House, so only bills promoted by Republicans tend to become law.

But those two GOP representatives who have been tilting at tobacco for years said they were moving on to other issues this year.

Stephens, who chairs the House Economic Development and Tourism Committee, is instead focusing on bread-and-butter issues for the bustling region he represents. His area is booming due to increased shipping traffic at its ports and the new Hyundai Metaplant, not to mention the visitors flocking to the coast and Georgia’s charming and oldest city, Savannah.

He said he would put his limited time this year into promoting tourism and managing growth “rather than introduce another bill that that won’t go anywhere.”

And Cooper is concerned about recreational use of the drug Kratom and the anesthetic ketamine.

The longtime lawmaker, sworn in the same year as Stephens, has watched a succession of lawmakers parade through the Capitol, including several House speakers. She remembers when smoke wafted through the air and left an awful smell on the faded blue curtains. She also has not forgotten the spittoons and carpet stains.

All that may have faded away, but the resistance to taxing tobacco has endured, Cooper said.

“There just doesn’t seem to be an appetite from members of the legislature for that to move,” she said. “It is the mystery of the century. I would like to know before I die, if we ever find out, what’s causing the resistance to it. They slip through taxes on other stuff.”

Georgia House Republican property tax elimination plan to face opposition from Senate Democrats

ATLANTA — A Republican House proposal to eliminate homeowner property taxes will face stiff opposition if it makes it to the state Senate, where Democratic leadership labeled it “draconian” and “unserious.”

Georgia’s property tax is essential, Sen. Harold Jones II, D-Augusta, said Thursday.

“It funds your schools and it funds your police,” said Jones, the Senate minority leader. “And that’s exactly what you would be defunding, quite frankly, if you actually went for either one of these proposals.”

The other proposal he was referring to was by Republican leaders of his own chamber to eliminate the state income tax.

Republicans would not necessarily need support from Democrats to change the income tax, but an overhaul of the property tax would require an amendment of the state constitution.

To pass the General Assembly, a constitutional amendment requires a two-thirds vote of approval from both the House and Senate. Republicans do not have a two-thirds majority in either chamber, so Democrats would have a say in the outcome.

House Speaker Jon Burns, R-Newington, unveiled the broad strokes of his chamber’s plan Wednesday, with a resolution calling for a constitutional amendment to gradually reduce and then eliminate the property tax on the primary residence of homeowners. He said the rapid rise in home values was driving an “unsustainable” increase in property tax bills.

The resolution requires companion legislation that gets into the details of how the tax break would work.

On Thursday, Rep. Shaw Blackmon, R-Bonaire, the architect of the plan, filed some of that companion legislation.

House Bill 1116 would gradually increase the tax break on primary residences, starting with a $10,000 maximum exemption off the taxable value through 2028, up from the current $2,000.

Blackmon said Wednesday that jurisdictions would be allowed to use up to 2 pennies of local sales tax revenue to make up for their lost property tax revenue, though the total sales tax rate that jurisdictions would be allowed to levy would remain at 5%.

Factories, offices, stores, apartments, second homes and other non-primary residences would still be subject to the traditional property tax.

But HB 1116 would require that cities, counties and school districts reduce their property tax rate to cap annual revenue growth at 3%. And it would require that these jurisdictions roll back their property tax rate if the amount of their sales tax revenue dedicated to offsetting the revenue lost to the homeowner property tax break were to exceed the cost of that tax break.

Jones said the increase in sales taxes needed to pay for the homeowner tax break would raise costs for families when they go shopping. And he said the tax break would also force local service cuts.

“Any idea of getting rid of the property tax is just draconian,” he said.

Jones also said the two-thirds vote requirement was a tough hurdle. “I think that’s going to be a hard one to get over,” he said. “I hope it will be a hard one to get over.”

Test-run of outdoor classrooms in Georgia schools clears General Assembly

ATLANTA —Students in Georgia schools could soon have more opportunities to study outdoors instead of inside a classroom.

The state Senate gave final approval Wednesday to a bill that calls for a pilot program that incorporates outdoor learning spaces at K-8 schools chosen by the state Department of Education.

The vote was unanimous, and the bill now heads to Gov. Brian Kemp after it previously passed the House.

“I was able to benefit greatly from an outdoor classroom at North Habersham Middle School,” said state Sen. Bo Hatchett, R-Cornelia. “Today’s students should also benefit from that same opportunity.”

State Sen. Sheikh Rahman, D-Lawrenceville, said time away from the confines of school buildings will help students.

“Our kids now, they spend so much time on the computer. They don’t go outside,” Rahman said. “The whole idea is getting children to spend more time outside with nature. It’s good for obesity and mental health. There will be a lot of benefits.”

Under Senate Bill 148, the outdoor education pilot program will last at least three school years, and then state legislators will evaluate its impact.

Republican state House leaders unveil plan to abolish homeowner property taxes

ATLANTA — Republicans in Georgia’s state House say they want to take steps to erase homeowner property taxes this legislative session, which is getting underway ahead of an election cycle seemingly dominated by concerns about the cost of living.

The proposal unveiled at the Capitol Wednesday by House leaders, would gradually chip away at the amount of property taxes homeowners pay on their primary residence, until the amount vanishes to zero in 2032.

“This historic tax relief will be delivering on our commitment to make life more affordable,” House Speaker Jon Burns, R-Newington, said Wednesday before releasing a resolution with outlines of the proposal. The way property taxes are levied now, based on fast-rising home values, is “unsustainable” for most homeowners, he said.

The abolishment of a core revenue stream for local communities is a major undertaking. Property taxes are not collected by state government, but they pay for most local services, from police to teachers.

The proposal, still being drafted by Burns’ team, would let cities, counties and schools make up some of the lost revenue by either increasing sales taxes or by shifting revenue from their current sales tax if it is already at the maximum under state law. It also would allow them to levy more property assessments for specific services, much like some jurisdictions bill for fire services.

Burns said that would increase transparency, since taxpayers would be able to see the line-item bill for each service.

But sales tax revenue is currently a larger revenue stream. Much of it is dedicated to road projects or to supplanting a portion of homeowners’ property tax bill. Sales taxes are also less reliable than property taxes, especially during a recession. That would make budgeting more difficult.

And some lost property tax revenue probably could not be replaced, some observers said, leading to cuts to local services.

Property taxes deliver at least $5 billion to fund operations in cities, counties and schools, said Clint Mueller, deputy director of the Association County Commissioners of Georgia.

“It means cutting services. It means raising taxes through assessments. It means shifting sales tax from other purposes like capital and general property tax relief across the board,” he said. Costs don’t “magically go away,” he said. 

The biggest local cost is typically the operation of school systems, a mandate under the state constitution. They are so big they are often the largest employer in the community, with 90% of revenue typically going to employee pay and benefits.

And property taxes cover all of that.

“No question that is the primary source of local revenue that school systems have, and it’s really the only way they can raise revenue,” said John Zauner, executive director of the Georgia School Superintendents Association.

Many districts levy a 1% sales tax, but it is typically used to cover capital costs, such as construction or technology purchases.

Zauner noted that some areas would find it difficult to raise much sales tax revenue to replace residential property taxes because they lack a significant industrial or commercial tax base.

“Some of the counties don’t even have a grocery store, let alone a Dollar General,” he said. “It’s just an imbalanced way to collect taxes.”

Striking the right balance of alternative revenue streams versus cuts will not be the only challenge.

To untie the Gordian Knot of Georgia’s property tax system, lawmakers will need voters to approve an amendment to the state constitution.

Before they can even get it to voters, they will have to get it through both chambers of the General Assembly with two-thirds votes in favor. That would mean securing votes from Democrats. It would also require collaboration from the Republican-controlled Senate, which has its own affordability priority.

Senate leaders have said they want to make deep annual cuts to the income tax, eventually eliminating it.

Sen. Blake Tillery, R-Vidalia, chairman of the Senate Appropriations Committee, noted that his chamber’s proposal does not call for an increase in the state’s portion of the sales tax.

The House has yet to release legislation with full details about how its property tax cut would work. Tillery said he looks forward to reading the details and to “working with the house to reduce the tax burden on all Georgians.”