Lawmakers question state budget cuts to criminal justice, public safety

ATLANTA – Georgia lawmakers on both sides of the aisle showed hesitation Wednesday to sign off on budget cuts Gov. Brian Kemp has proposed for criminal justice and public safety agencies through July 2021.

The state’s prisons, courts, police and public-defender agencies would see reductions of roughly $80 million to $100 million this fiscal year, according to Kemp’s proposed budget.

On the second day of legislative hearings on the $28.1 billion fiscal 2021 budget plan, many agency heads assured members of the House and Senate Appropriations committees they can mostly stomach the belt tightening. But lawmakers seemed less keen on many of the cuts outlined Wednesday morning.

“I think we all have a responsibility to reduce the fat, but we need to be careful not to be overzealous and cut into the muscle of the criminal justice system,” said Sen. Randy Robertson, R-Cataula, a retired major with the Muscogee County Sheriff’s Office.

Agencies across state government are working to comply with the governor’s order to reduce their spending by 4% this fiscal year and 6% in fiscal 2021, which begins July 1. Kemp ordered the cuts last summer in response to sluggish tax revenue collections.

On Wednesday, lawmakers highlighted a disconnect between the proposed cuts and a growing prison population in Georgia. With nearly 54,000 inmates currently, Georgia Corrections Department Commissioner Timothy Ward expects to see an increase of 15,000 inmates over the next few years.

That comes as the prison system is being asked to trim around $47 million this fiscal year and $54 in fiscal 2021, mostly by upgrading technology and shrinking administrative costs. Ward said about two dozen employees lost jobs as part of the budget reductions.

Those cuts and others discussed Wednesday gave Rep. Al Williams pause. He said a much closer look is needed to avoid creating unexpected costs elsewhere in Georgia’s criminal justice system.

“Whether you end up paying on the front end or the back end, it’s going to cost you,” said Williams, D-Midway. “It’s a difficult time.”

The feeling was mutual for Georgia Supreme Court Chief Justice Harold Melton. He highlighted cuts totaling about $3.5 million to the state’s accountability courts, a popular program created under former Gov. Nathan Deal that provides alternative sentencing for thousands of inmates.

House Appropriations Committee Chairman Terry England also singled out the accountability courts, noting lawmakers may want to tread cautiously with a program many criminal justice advocates feel is working.

“We certainly want to take a closer look at that,” said England, R-Auburn. “We put a lot of time and energy into that over the years.”

Other lawmakers homed in Wednesday on cuts to Georgia’s public defenders and the forensic crime lab run by the Georgia Bureau of Investigation.

To absorb cuts, the Georgia Public Defender’s Council furloughed employees for a day and instituted a hiring freeze to meet the cuts.

Asked whether the office could handle those cuts on top of an already heavy caseload, Interim Executive Director Jimmonique Rodgers showed some doubt.

“To be honest, I cannot guarantee that,” Rodgers said. “We will work to the best of our abilities to identify efficiencies.”

GBI’s crime lab would lose about $1.6 million by leaving a handful of unfilled jobs vacant. Those cuts would come as the agency struggles to clear a backlog of more than 44,000 cases in its crime lab, which Director Vic Reynolds said is far too many.

“The reality is we can’t become what we want to become with these numbers,” Reynolds said.

Crime-lab cuts would be balanced with additional funds for a new criminal gangs task force Kemp formed last year. Arresting and prosecuting gang members is a top priority for Kemp in 2020. The state may have about 70,000 gang members at large with another 30,000 either in prison or on probation, Reynolds said.

But with more resources to fight gangs, officials said the state will continue struggling to offer quality services for the nearly 12,000 inmates and thousands more probationers with mental health issues. High costs for crisis-intervention care and prescription drugs have made it tough to keep mentally ill Georgians from landing in jail, said Community Supervision Department Commissioner Michael Nail.

“The (mental health) system has made significant improvement from 10 years ago,” Nail said. “But we’re nowhere close to where we need to go, and it’s simply because of capacity.”

Rep. Darlene Taylor, R-Thomasville, traced a lack of mental health services to instances of repeat crimes that she said are cropping up especially in rural parts of Georgia.

“I’m pleased that we’re looking for ways to be more efficient,” Taylor said, “But I am concerned about health care and mental health.”

Meanwhile, the Georgia General Assembly’s longest-serving member, Rep. Calvin Smyre, stressed that it’s still early in the budget ballgame. He thinks some funding issues may “take care of themselves” as the legislative session rolls on and the state gets a better sense of its economic outlook.

“I just want to make sure that when we make the cuts, that it does not decrease services,” said Smyre, D-Columbus.

Bill filed to end discrimination against hair styles in Georgia

ATLANTA – Protections are being sought by Georgia Senate Democrats against racial discrimination toward hair styles like braids, locks and twists.

Pre-filed earlier this month, Senate Bill 286 would bar employers, landlords and school officials from discriminating against hair styles including “braids, locks, twists or other textured hair-dressing historically associated with an individual’s race.”

The legislation, sponsored by Sen. Tonya Anderson, mimics state legislation first passed in California last year aimed at criminalizing unfair firings or housing denials based on natural hair styles. Called the “CROWN Act,” that legislation has also been brought at the federal level via a bill filed last month in the U.S. Senate.

Echoing the CROWN Act’s language, the Georgia bill frames hair-style discrimination as a source of historical discrimination against black people especially.

“Despite the great strides American society and laws have made to reverse the racist ideology that black traits are inferior, hair remains a rampant source of racial discrimination with serious economic and health consequences,” the Georgia bill says.

Sen. Nikema Williams, who also serves as chairwoman of the Georgia Democratic Party, said on social media that the bill should curb discrimination black people in the state face over hair styles.

“It’s time Georgia ends hair-based discrimination in our institutions,” said Williams, D-Atlanta, a cosponsor of Anderson’s bill.

Though susceptible to controversy, the hairstyle bill probably won’t spark the kind of charged debate seen with other political issues involving race like drug enforcement or police accountability, said Emory University Professor Andra Gillespie. Sparring would more likely stem from generational gaps between younger and older lawmakers who differ in their views of socially acceptable workplace attire, she said.

“There could be an ‘OK, boomer,’ moment here,” said Gillespie, who specializes in African American political science. “You just have to wait and see if anybody does it.”

Still, Gillespie said the nationwide legislative push signals black lawmakers are hearing their constituents want these protections prioritized as workplaces grow more diverse.

“These kinds of things have come up in the past,” Gillespie said. “They are likely to continue to come up as corporate and social institutions continue to diversify.”

Georgia agriculture chief warns budget cuts will mean fewer food safety inspections

Gary Black

Story by Dave Williams and Beau Evans

ATLANTA – Most state agency heads who appeared before legislative budget writers Tuesday vowed to do more with less to meet the spending-reduction targets Gov. Brian Kemp has set for them.

But Georgia Commissioner of Agriculture Gary Black warned job losses in his department could seriously hamper the state’s No.1 industry.

On the first day of hearings on Kemp’s $28.1 billion fiscal 2021 budget plan, Black said he has been forced to eliminate 18 full-time vacancies, four part-time vacancies, phase out six employees and cut loose four call-center workers by not renewing their contract.

“These critical positions in food safety, animal industry, meat inspection and marketing were not held in reserve on the books,” Black told members of the Georgia House and Senate Appropriations Committees. “These were vacant positions we would have tried to fill, but due to a competitive job market, we have been unable to find qualified applicants.”

With state tax revenue growing far slower than had been anticipated, Kemp ordered most state agencies last summer to reduce spending by 4% during this fiscal year and 6% during fiscal 2021, which begins in July.

Most department heads who presented their budgets to lawmakers Tuesday expressed confidence they would be able to hit those targets without hurting services.

“Our cuts were designed to minimize any impact on our operations,” said Richard Dunn, director of the Georgia Environmental Protection Division. “I believe we’ve accomplished that.”

Some lawmakers noted the difference in tone between agency heads elected by Georgia voters like Black and several Kemp-appointed department officials who spoke Tuesday afternoon.

Elected officials seemed more willing to open up about concerns over the potential impact of cuts, said state Sen. Jen Jordan, D-Atlanta. Kemp’s department heads painted a rosier picture, she said.

“It just makes me wonder what the agency heads really think about the cuts they’ve had to make,” Jordan said after Tuesday’s hearing.

She expects a deeper dive on reduction details in upcoming subcommittee meetings might shed more light on operational and staffing impacts if the cuts take effect.

“I think there are going to be a lot of really unhappy people in this state,” Jordan said.

For his part, Black said he has never viewed “across-the-board” cuts as good strategic planning.

Rep. Carolyn Hugley, D-Columbus, expressed concerns over whether the job losses would affect food safety in Georgia.

“What is our obligation to the public?” she asked Black.

“You have my word that the team we have on the ground will do its job every day,” Black answered. “But with reductions in staff, you simply can’t cover the territory as frequently as you’d like to.”

Black said his budget also calls for a $161,000 cut in the popular Georgia Grown program, which markets the state’s farm products.

The agriculture department also needs $1 million to jump-start the growth of industrial hemp in Georgia, a lucrative crop the General Assembly voted to legalize last year.

Kemp’s budget proposes giving the new Georgia Access to Medical Cannabis Commission $200,000 this fiscal year and just under $155,000 for fiscal 2021. Part of Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger’s office, the commission is the oversight arm of Georgia’s fledgling medical cannabis sector.

But those funding amounts “may be inadequate” to run the cannabis commission full-steam, Raffensperger said Tuesday, noting his staff wants a budget closer to $500,000.

Employees at the Public Service Commission would have to take five furlough days per year to meet the budget cuts, said Commissioner Chuck Eaton, who was elected chairman of the PSC Tuesday by his commission colleagues.  He said the furloughs and other cuts would make it tougher for the agency to regulate the state’s energy utilities.

“We are way down to the bone,” Eaton said at Tuesday’s hearing. “There is no discretionary spending left.”

The Department of Driver Services plans to cut nearly $1.4 million this fiscal year and $2.3 million next year by eliminating vacant staff positions in the busy license issuance branch and renewing more licenses online via the federal REAL ID program, said DDS Commissioner Spencer Moore.

“This is our effort to modernize,” Moore said.

Gov. Kemp aims three bills at human trafficking

Gov. Brian Kemp and First Lady Marty Kemp

ATLANTA – Gov. Brian Kemp Tuesday unveiled the specifics of a crackdown on human trafficking he proposed in more broad terms in last week’s State of the State address to the General Assembly.

Kemp asked the legislature to support three bills that would tighten restrictions in existing state law targeting human traffickers and, in one case, implement a federal rule promulgated last year by the U.S. Department of Transportation.

When he took office last year, Kemp made going after human traffickers a high priority, citing Georgia’s unenviable status as a state with one of the highest rates of human trafficking in the nation. He formed a state commission to tackle the issue and installed his wife, first lady Marty Kemp, as one of three co-chairs.

“We’ve been working around the clock for the past year … fighting this fight to end human trafficking,” Kemp said during a ceremony announcing his bills. “These pieces of legislation represent a bold next step in this fight.”

The bills Kemp plans to introduce during the coming days would:

  • allow victims of human trafficking to restrict access to their criminal records. Victims caught up in prostitution networks formed by traffickers often have trouble finding jobs and/or places to live.
  • close a loophole in the state’s sex offender registry law that does not require Georgians convicted of a felony for keeping a place of prostitution, pimping and pandering to register as a sex offender. The legislation also would criminalize improper sexual contact by a foster parent .
  • allow the state to revoke the commercial driver’s license of anyone convicted of trafficking an individual for labor servitude or sexual servitude, in accordance with a new federal rule.

First Lady Marty Kemp said the need to add foster parents to the state’s improper sexual contact code was brought to the GRACE Commission’s attention by an actual case.

“There is no consent between a foster parent and a child in his or her custody,” she said. “The law needs to reflect that.”

Lt. Gov. Geoff Duncan, a member of the GRACE Commission, said stories from victims of human trafficking around the state helped generate the legislative package Kemp unveiled Tuesday.

“We’ve taken these opportunities to create legislation that’s going to truly make a difference,” he said.

“We care about the vulnerable, the forgotten, the hurting,” added Georgia House Speaker Pro Tempore Jan Jones, R-Milton, another of the commission’s co-chairs. “The perpetrators will have no safe harbor in Georgia.”

Georgia eyes new tech for transportation agency

A traffic signal display at the Transportation Tech Showcase on Jan. 21, 2020.

Mobile apps warning drivers that someone is about to run a red light. A button that MARTA bus operators can tap to ask for a green light. Computer programs pinpointing when a car has stalled on the side of the highway.

These tech features and more were on display Tuesday at the first annual Transportation Tech Showcase, held at the Georgia Freight Depot in downtown Atlanta. Transit-focused companies, government officials and state lawmakers were on hand to peruse tech offerings touted as solutions for easing traffic congestion in metro Atlanta and hustling freight up from the coast.

Among the gadgets and gear rolled out for public viewing Tuesday were new signals set up at traffic intersections that can send potentially life-saving information to drivers. Installed in a car’s radio system, the signals alert drivers when a traffic light is about to change colors, when a pedestrian is in a crosswalk or when another car is about to run a red light.

The signals both improve safety for today’s drivers and help lay the groundwork for automated driving technology in the future, said Alan Davis, the assistant state traffic engineer. Around 430 signals have been installed at intersections in the metro Atlanta area so far and another 1,600 will soon go up statewide at a cost of around $10 million, Davis said.

On Tuesday, Gov. Brian Kemp announced another 1,000 signals will be installed in the metro area by city and county governments, paid mostly via federal grant funds. State officials will work with the Atlanta Regional Commission to install them.

“This…is a powerful testament to what we all know to be true: Our state is moving in the right direction toward solutions,” Kemp said Tuesday.

The technology showcase came as state lawmakers began a week-long debate over Kemp’s proposed budget across the street at the Capitol. The Georgia Department of Transportation was spared budget cuts in the 2020 and 2021 fiscal years that the governor ordered for most state agencies over summer.

The transportation department’s proposed budget this fiscal year is hovering around $3.7 billion, nearly half of which would come from federal funds.

It’s unlikely any major transportation bills will come out of the current legislative session that started last week, said Senate Transportation Committee Chairman Brandon Beach, R-Alpharetta. At least, no legislation similar in scale to a 2015 measure that raised the state’s gas tax. Enacted under then-Gov. Nathan Deal, the tax has since reeled in about $900 million a year for state road construction and maintenance projects.

House Transportation Committee Chairman Kevin Tanner, R-Dawsonville, has a bill still alive this session that would drum up more money for public transit in rural areas.

But Tuesday’s program did figure into Lt. Gov. Geoff Duncan’s push for more state investment in new transportation technologies and public-private partnerships to bring them into reality. Duncan unveiled a new task force last week on technology research and development that aims to “make Georgia the technology capital of the East Coast.”

“Government’s just not very nimble at times about certain things,” Duncan said Tuesday. “Being able to partner with the private sector in a way that allows us to push the biggest and best ideas out into the market quicker is, I believe, the best way forward.”